Fishing at Horsethief Reservoir
Fishing Information
Bait and Tackle
Boating
Food
Gas Stations
Lodging
Fishing in Idaho
Idaho Fishing Information
Idaho Lakes
Idaho Reports
Idaho Photos
Idaho Tournaments
Catch More Fish
How to Videos
How to Articles
Fishing Reports
Fishing Gear
From The Forum
Freshwater Fishing
Boats, Motors, Trailers
Rods, Reels, and Tackle
State Discussion
Latest Idaho Report
American Falls Reservoir - Fished on the south west side beach just north of the boat ramp. Using worm and orange corky off the bottom. Caught two fish, one weighed 4.5 l... Continued
- Fishing Details
- Fishing Reports
- Catch Photos
- Solar Lunar Charts
- Local Businesses
Horsethief Reservoir is a Reservoir in Valley, Idaho.
Do you have a question about Horsethief Reservoir, ask it here.
Horsethief is managed as a rainbow trout fishery and is a popular summer destination for anglers and other recreationists.
Large numbers of catchable size rainbow trout are stocked in the spring and fall months to maintain good fishing. The Idaho Department of Fish and Game drained and poisoned Horsethief in 2006 to get rid of unwanted perch that overpopulated the reservoir. The agency restocked it spring 2007 with rainbow and brown trout.
Public fishing docks and ramps for small boats.
Travel through Cascade on Highway 55. Just north of town, turn east on the Warm Lake Highway and travel 6 miles to the Horsethief Reservoir turnoff on the south side of the road; then travel 3 miles south to the reservoir.
Idaho - American Falls Reservoir Fishing Report
Fished on the south west side beach just north of the boat ramp. Using worm and orange corky off the bottom. Caught two fish, one weighed 4.5 lbs an... Continued
Idaho - Kelso Lake Fishing Report
Off the dock caught m,y limit with green power bait, #18 treble and a slip weight. They like red if it's cloudy.
... Continued
Idaho - Weston Creek Reservoir Fishing Report
i caught 10 largies using a little muskie lure. almost all small fish caught. (biggest one caught was about only 10 inches. :(...... Continued
Solar Lunar Best Fishing Times - Horsethief Reservoir, Idaho
Horsethief Reservoir, Idaho - Solar Lunar Chart - May 25, 2012
Moon Phase ![]() | Waxing Crescent | Sun Phase ![]() |
Rise 4:06 Transit 11:40 Set 19:16 | Fish Major Periods 15:05 - 17:35 0:00 - 0:00 | Activity Minor Periods 22:19 - 23:49 7:44 - 9:14 | Day Rating |
Horsethief Reservoir, Idaho - Solar Lunar Chart - May 26, 2012
Moon Phase ![]() | Waxing Crescent | Sun Phase ![]() |
Rise 4:05 Transit 11:40 Set 19:16 | Fish Major Periods 15:53 - 18:23 0:00 - 0:00 | Activity Minor Periods 0:00 - 0:00 8:47 - 10:17 | Day Rating |
Horsethief Reservoir, Idaho - Solar Lunar Chart - May 27, 2012
Moon Phase ![]() | Waxing Crescent | Sun Phase ![]() |
Rise 4:05 Transit 11:40 Set 19:17 | Fish Major Periods 16:40 - 19:10 0:42 - 3:12 | Activity Minor Periods 0:00 - 0:00 9:53 - 11:23 | Day Rating |
Horsethief Reservoir, Idaho - Solar Lunar Chart - May 28, 2012
Moon Phase ![]() | First Quarter at 12:20 | Sun Phase ![]() |
Rise 4:04 Transit 11:41 Set 19:18 | Fish Major Periods 17:27 - 19:57 1:30 - 4:00 | Activity Minor Periods 0:00 - 0:00 11:01 - 12:31 | Day Rating |
Horsethief Reservoir, Idaho - Solar Lunar Chart - May 29, 2012
Moon Phase ![]() | Waxing Gibbous | Sun Phase ![]() |
Rise 4:03 Transit 11:41 Set 19:19 | Fish Major Periods 18:16 - 20:46 2:17 - 4:47 | Activity Minor Periods 0:00 - 0:00 12:11 - 13:41 | Day Rating |
Businesses Located Near Horsethief Reservoir
Boating
- Cya Sports Incorporated
- 1470 S Main St
- Cascade, Idaho
- (208) 382-4386
- Cheap Thrills Rentals
- 303 N 3rd St
- McCall, Idaho
- (208) 634-7472
- McCall Power Sport Rentals
- 114 N 3rd St, Ste B
- McCall, Idaho
- (208) 634-8200
Food
- Vigilantes Restaurant & Lounge
- 263 N Mission St
- McCall, Idaho
- (208) 325-4005
- Moxie Java
- 312 E Lake St
- McCall, Idaho
- (208) 634-3607
- Valley Club
- 115 N Main St
- Cascade, Idaho
- (208) 382-3416
Gas / Convenience Store
- Howdy's Gas & Grub
- 503 N Main St
- Cascade, Idaho
- (208) 382-6712
- Harpo's Chevron
- 823 S Main St
- Cascade, Idaho
- (208) 382-3181
- Garden Valley/Chevron Store
- 1086 Highway 17
- Garden Valley, Idaho
- (208) 462-3869
Lodging
- Taj McCall Vacation Rental Cabin
- 925 Fairway Dr
- McCall, Idaho
- (208) 371-4935
- Beautiful Luxury Vacation Home Rentals
- 13130 Hawks Bay Rd.
- Donnelly, Idaho
- (208) 573-1489
- Mc Call Vacations
- 805 N 3rd St
- McCall, Idaho
- (208) 634-7056

































